QuikTool

FD vs RD vs PPF: which is better after tax?

Published

A fixed deposit, a recurring deposit and a PPF account all pay a steady, predictable return, so people compare them on the rate. But the rate hides the tax. Interest from an FD or RD is taxed every year and PPF interest is not, and for someone in a high slab that decides which is better.

Try it now: FD Calculator, RD Calculator, PPF Calculator.

How do an FD, an RD and PPF differ?

An FD is one deposit for a fixed time at a fixed rate, and a cumulative FD pays everything at the end. An RD is a monthly instalment for a fixed time, and each instalment earns interest only from the day it is paid, so the average rupee works for about half the term. PPF is a government account where you deposit up to 1,50,000 a year for 15 years at a rate the government sets each quarter, currently 7.1 percent. Banks usually offer RDs for up to 10 years, so a 15-year RD is shown here only for comparison.

What does an FD leave after tax?

Take 1,00,000 in an FD for 5 years at 7 percent compounded quarterly. It grows to 1,41,477.82, an interest of 41,477.82. At the 30 percent slab plus 4 percent cess, tax is 31.2 percent, so the tax comes to 12,941.08 and you keep 28,536.74 of the interest. The money after tax is 1,28,536.74. Try your own figures in the FD calculator, which has a tax box for this.

How do an RD and PPF compare on the same instalment?

Put 6,000 a month into each for 15 years, 10,80,000 in all. The RD calculator at 7 percent compounded quarterly gives 19,06,093.31 before tax, of which 8,26,093.31 is interest. At 31.2 percent tax on the interest is 2,57,741.11, which leaves 16,48,352.20. In PPF at 7.1 percent the same instalments reach 18,93,406 with no tax. For someone in the 30 percent slab, PPF is ahead by 2,45,053.80.

How do I pick one for a goal?

Start with the date you need the money. For a goal within five years, such as a down payment or a course fee, use an FD if you have the whole amount now, or an RD if you will save it month by month. For money you will not touch for 15 years, such as retirement, PPF is hard to beat on safety and tax. Break the goal into the time and the amount, and run the matching calculator for each.

When does the taxed deposit win?

When your slab is low. Someone who pays no tax keeps the whole 19,06,093.31 from the RD, which is more than PPF’s 18,93,406. At a higher slab, PPF’s tax-free rate of 7.1 percent matches a taxable deposit paying 10.32 percent for someone taxed at 31.2 percent, and no bank pays that. PPF also has limits: a 15-year lock-in, a yearly cap and a rate that can change. An FD or RD is the right tool for a goal within a few years, and PPF for the long run. The PPF calculator shows both the schedule and the goal.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is the interest on a bank FD taxed every year?
Yes. Interest on a cumulative FD is taxed each year as it accrues, even though you receive it only at maturity, and banks may deduct tax at source above a limit. The tax box in the calculator applies one rate to all the interest, so it is an estimate.
Can I use PPF for a short-term goal?
Not well. The account runs for 15 years, and withdrawals before that are limited. For a goal within a few years use an FD or RD, and keep PPF for long-term money.
Is a senior citizen better off with an FD?
Often yes. Senior citizens usually get a higher FD rate, and their tax limits are higher, so the after-tax gap to PPF is smaller or disappears. Compare the after-tax figures with your own slab.

Try the tools

See all guides