QuikTool

Old or new tax regime? Six salary examples compared

Published

Every year a salaried person in India can pick the old or the new tax regime, and most people choose by habit or by what colleagues do. The better way is to work out both. This guide does that for six salaries with typical deductions, so you can see where your own case falls.

Try it now: Income Tax Calculator, HRA Calculator.

What decides which regime is cheaper?

The new regime has a 75,000 standard deduction, wide slabs and no tax up to 12 lakh of taxable income, but almost no other deductions. The old regime has a 50,000 standard deduction and steeper slabs, but lets you subtract HRA, investments, health insurance, extra NPS and home loan interest. So the question is whether your deductions are large enough to make up for the steeper slabs. The income tax calculator works out both for you.

How do six salaries compare?

Each example is a salaried person under 60 with no other income. The deductions are: 1,50,000 of investments, 25,000 of health insurance, 50,000 of extra NPS, the HRA exemption shown, and 2,00,000 of home loan interest where stated. Tax includes 4 percent cess.

SalaryOld regime deductionsNew regime taxOld regime taxCheaper
12,00,000None01,63,800New
15,00,0001,75,00097,5002,02,800New
18,00,0004,05,000 with HRA of 1,80,0001,50,8002,24,640New
25,00,0006,65,000 with HRA of 2,40,000 and home loan interest3,19,8003,61,920New
40,00,0007,25,000 with HRA of 3,00,000 and home loan interest7,87,8008,11,200New
30,00,0008,75,000 with HRA of 4,00,000, parents’ health cover and home loan interest4,75,8004,52,400Old

Why does the new regime usually win?

Because its slabs are far kinder. The 12 lakh rebate means a salary of 12,00,000 pays nothing, while the same salary pays 1,63,800 in the old regime without deductions. Even at 40 lakh, with 7,25,000 of deductions, the new regime is cheaper by 23,400. The deductions have to be large before they pay back the higher old-regime slabs. The income tax guide shows the break-even at several salaries.

When does the old regime win?

When you can claim nearly every deduction at the same time. The sixth example is a salary of 30,00,000 with 1,50,000 of investments, health insurance of 25,000 for you and 50,000 for senior-citizen parents, 50,000 of extra NPS, an HRA exemption of 4,00,000 and 2,00,000 of home loan interest. That is 8,75,000 in all, and the old regime costs 4,52,400 against 4,75,800 in the new regime, a saving of 23,400. Take away the home loan interest and the new regime wins again.

A large HRA exemption is the usual reason. It needs high rent in a city where the 50 percent limit applies, as the HRA guide explains.

How do I decide for myself?

Add up the deductions you will really claim this year, not the ones you could claim. Investments you would make anyway, such as PPF or EPF, count. Investments made only to save tax do not, because that money is locked up. Then compare the two taxes in the calculator. If the old regime is ahead by only a small amount, the new regime is often the better choice, since it needs no proofs and no locked-in investments. Salaried employees can choose again each year and tell their employer, so the choice is not permanent.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch between regimes every year?
Salaried employees without business income can choose a regime each year, telling their employer at the start of the year and making the final choice when they file the return. People with business income can switch back to the old regime only once, so check before you opt in.
Do I lose my PPF and EPF if I choose the new regime?
No. You keep the accounts and the interest rules do not change. You only lose the tax deduction on the amount you pay in, which the new regime does not allow for most deductions.
Which regime is better for a first job?
Almost always the new one. A first salary rarely comes with large HRA, home loan or insurance deductions, and the new regime needs no proofs. Compare both once your deductions grow.

Try the tools

See all guides