QuikTool

Buy or rent a home: what the numbers say

Published

Whether to buy or rent is partly about life, not money: owning gives security and a home that is yours. But the money question is real, and it can be put in numbers. This guide compares the two over 20 years with stated assumptions you can change, and shows what has to be true for buying to win.

Try it now: Home Loan EMI Calculator, SIP Calculator.

What are we comparing?

One person buys a flat for 80,00,000. They pay 16,00,000 as a down payment and borrow 64,00,000 at 8.5 percent for 20 years, so the EMI is 55,540.69. Another person rents a similar flat for 20,000 a month, with the rent rising 5 percent a year. The renter invests the 16,00,000 down payment on day one, and every month invests whatever the EMI exceeds the rent by. After 20 years the buyer owns a flat with no loan, and the renter owns a portfolio.

How do the 20-year results compare?

The renter’s result depends on the return, and the buyer’s on how fast the flat grows in price. This table uses the home loan EMI calculator figures and a monthly investment return.

Flat grows atFlat worth after 20 yearsRenter invests at 10%Renter invests at 8%
5% a year2,12,26,381.643,24,28,316.252,34,42,694.35
7% a year3,09,57,475.703,24,28,316.252,34,42,694.35
8% a year3,72,87,657.153,24,28,316.252,34,42,694.35

How fast must the flat grow for buying to win?

Against a renter earning 10 percent, the flat must grow about 7.2 percent a year, which is faster than many people assume, so check the price history of your own city. Against a renter earning 8 percent, the break-even is about 5.5 percent. So buying looks better when investment returns are modest and prices rise quickly, and renting looks better when investments do well. The SIP calculator shows what regular investing can grow to.

How should I use this on my own numbers?

Change the inputs that matter most: the price and down payment, the loan rate, the rent in your area and the return you honestly expect from investing. Then check how far the flat must grow to tie. If that figure looks high for your city, renting and investing is ahead on paper. If it looks easy to reach, buying is. Either way, keep a margin of error, because 20 years is long and every input will move.

What does the comparison leave out?

A lot, and some of it favours buying. It leaves out stamp duty and registration, brokerage, maintenance and property tax, all of which cost the buyer. It also leaves out the old-regime deduction for home loan interest, tax on the renter’s investment gains, the chance that returns fall short, and the discipline needed to invest the gap every month. Some renters spend the difference instead, while a loan forces the buyer to save. The comparison also treats the flat as an investment, though it is also where you live. The home loan guide explains how the loan itself behaves.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent while I save a bigger down payment?
Often yes. A bigger down payment means a smaller loan and less interest, and waiting costs only the rent you would pay anyway. But if prices in your city are rising fast, waiting can raise the price faster than you save, so run both cases.
Does the home loan tax deduction change the answer?
It helps the buyer, but only in the old regime and only up to 2,00,000 of interest a year, so it moves the break-even a little and rarely changes the result by itself. Use the tax note in the home loan calculator to see the interest figure.
What if rent rises faster than 5 percent?
Then renting becomes less attractive, because the gap you can invest shrinks and the rent itself grows. Faster rent growth moves the break-even in favour of buying, so change the figures to match your city.

Try the tools

See all guides