QuikTool

Lumpsum vs SIP: which grows more, and what the comparison leaves out

Published

If you have a sum to invest, you can invest it all today or spread it over months. The two do not give the same result, and the gap is bigger than most people expect. This guide compares them on paper, explains the gap, and then says honestly what such a comparison cannot tell you.

Try it now: Lumpsum vs SIP Calculator, SIP Calculator.

What is the difference between a lumpsum and a SIP?

A lumpsum puts the whole amount into an investment at once. A SIP, a systematic investment plan, puts in a fixed smaller amount every month. They can use the same fund. The difference is how long each rupee stays invested: all of the lumpsum is invested from the first day, while a SIP invests a little each month and the rest waits in your bank account.

How do the two compare at a steady return?

Take 12,00,000, a return of 12 percent a year and 10 years. As a lumpsum it grows to 39,60,464.27. As a SIP of 10,000 a month, which uses up the same 12,00,000 over the 120 months, it grows to 23,23,390.76. The lumpsum ends 16,37,073.51 ahead, or 70.46 percent more. Both use the same return, and the same total is put in. Only the timing differs. The lumpsum vs SIP calculator runs your own numbers.

Why does a SIP end with so much less?

Because most SIP rupees are invested for far less time. The first monthly amount grows for all 10 years, but the last grows for one month. On average, each rupee of this SIP is invested for about 5 years, half the period, while every rupee of the lumpsum is invested for 10. Compounding rewards time, so the money that goes in early does most of the work.

How does the gap change with time and return?

The longer the period, the larger the gap. For 24,00,000 at 10 percent, the lumpsum ends this far ahead of a SIP of the same total:

PeriodLumpsum ahead by
1 year4.63%
5 years26.43%
20 years129.69%

Why do people still choose a SIP?

Most people do not have a lumpsum to invest. Their money arrives as a monthly salary, and a SIP puts it to work as it comes. A SIP also takes away the question of when to invest. When markets fall, a SIP buys more units at lower prices, and the calculator, which assumes a steady return, cannot show that. A lumpsum put in just before a fall can lose money in the short run, which a SIP would have softened. So the calculator shows what waiting costs when markets rise, not that a SIP is a worse choice. The SIP calculator shows what a monthly SIP grows to.

Can I split a lumpsum over a few months instead?

Yes, and it is a common middle path for a windfall: invest part now and the rest over several months. The calculator shows the cost of that waiting. For 24,00,000 at 10 percent over one year, spreading the money over 12 months ends 1,17,255.13 behind the lumpsum, which is 4.63 percent. Spreading it over fewer months costs less, and the choice is about how much risk of a fall you are willing to accept. To live off a lumpsum, see the SWP guide.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is a lumpsum riskier than a SIP?
In the short run it can be, because all the money meets the market on one day. If prices fall soon after, the whole amount falls. A SIP spreads that risk across many prices. Over a long period the difference in risk shrinks, though the timing gap in returns remains.
Should I put a lumpsum into a SIP?
Investing a lumpsum by a SIP over a few months is a way to reduce the risk of bad timing. It costs some expected return when markets rise, as the comparison shows. Many people choose a short period, such as three to twelve months, so the cost stays small.
Do the results include tax and charges?
No. Both results ignore tax on gains, fund charges and the interest the SIP money might earn while it waits in a bank. They are for comparing the two ways of investing, not for predicting your final amount.

Try the tools

See all guides