QuikTool

Lumpsum vs SIP Calculator

Compare investing a sum all at once with spreading it over a SIP, at the same return, year by year.

The lumpsum, or the total spread over the SIP.

A number you choose, the same every month. Not a promise.

Lumpsum ends as
39,60,464.27
SIP ends as
23,23,390.76
Gap
16,37,073.51
Lumpsum is ahead by
70.46%
Monthly SIP amount
10,000.00
Months of SIP
120

This assumes a steady positive return, so the lumpsum always comes out ahead: all of the money is invested from the first day, while the SIP money waits and is invested one month at a time. Real markets rise and fall, and a SIP buys more when prices are low, so this shows the cost of waiting, not which choice will do better.

YearPut into the SIP so farLumpsum valueSIP valueGap
11,20,000.0013,52,190.041,28,093.2812,24,096.76
22,40,000.0015,23,681.582,72,432.0012,51,249.58
33,60,000.0017,16,922.544,35,076.4712,81,846.07
44,80,000.0019,34,671.296,18,348.3413,16,322.95
56,00,000.0021,80,036.048,24,863.6713,55,172.37
67,20,000.0024,56,519.1710,57,570.3113,98,948.86
78,40,000.0027,68,067.2913,19,789.9714,48,277.32
89,60,000.0031,19,127.5116,15,265.6515,03,861.86
910,80,000.0035,14,710.9519,48,215.0515,66,495.90
1012,00,000.0039,60,464.2723,23,390.7616,37,073.51

An estimate. The SIP uses the same method as the SIP calculator on this site: the monthly return is the yearly return ÷ 12, and each amount is invested at the start of its month. Tax and charges are not included. Nothing you enter is sent anywhere or remembered.

Runs in your browser. Nothing is uploaded.

What is Lumpsum vs SIP Calculator?

When you have a sum of money to invest, you can put it all in at once, which is a lumpsum, or you can spread it over months, which is a SIP. A lumpsum vs SIP calculator puts the same total through both at the same return, so you can see what each ends up as. The comparison is a good way to understand how time in the market and averaging work, and it often settles the question for people who wonder whether to wait before investing a windfall.

Enter the total amount, the yearly return you expect and the number of years. The lumpsum is invested on the first day. The SIP splits the same total into equal monthly amounts over all the years. Both grow at the same steady return, using the same monthly convention as the SIP calculator on this site, so the SIP result matches that page. You get both final values, the gap between them, and a table that shows them year by year.

Read the result with care. With a steady positive return the lumpsum always wins, because all of the money is invested from the start and the SIP money waits in the bank. Real markets are not steady. They fall as well as rise, and a SIP buys more when prices are low. So this comparison shows the cost of waiting when returns are positive, and not a forecast of which choice will do better. Everything is worked out in your browser.

How to use

  1. Enter the total amount you have to invest.
  2. Enter the yearly return you expect and the number of years.
  3. Read the final value of the lumpsum, the final value of the SIP and the gap.
  4. See the monthly SIP amount that spreads your money over the whole period.
  5. Use the table to see how the two grow year by year.

Example

Input

12,00,000 at 12% for 10 years

Output

Lumpsum 3,960,464.27; SIP of 10,000 a month 2,323,390.76; the lumpsum is 1,637,073.51 (70.46%) ahead

The same total at 10% for different periods

How much further ahead a lumpsum ends than a SIP of the same total.

SyntaxMeaning
24,00,000 for 1 yearThe lumpsum ends 4.63% ahead of the SIP
24,00,000 for 5 yearsThe lumpsum ends 26.43% ahead
24,00,000 for 20 yearsThe lumpsum ends 129.69% ahead

Frequently asked questions

Is a lumpsum better than a SIP?
If the return is steady and positive, yes, because the whole amount works from the first day. The result is the same total invested in both cases, but the SIP money spends part of the time uninvested. In real markets the outcome depends on what prices do, and a SIP can come out ahead when the market falls early on.
Why does a SIP end with so much less?
In the SIP the first monthly amount is invested for the whole period, but the last one only for a month. On average each rupee is invested for about half the time. With 12 percent for 10 years, the lumpsum is invested for all 10 years and the average SIP rupee for about 5.
Does the calculator use the same method as the SIP calculator?
Yes. It uses the standard convention there: the monthly return is the yearly return divided by 12 and each SIP amount is invested at the start of its month. The SIP value here equals the SIP calculator’s value for the same monthly amount.
Should I wait for the market to fall before investing a lumpsum?
The calculator cannot answer that, because it assumes a steady return. In practice nobody can time the market reliably. People who worry about investing just before a fall often use a middle path, such as a staggered investment over a few months, which you can test by entering a short period.
Are the returns guaranteed?
No. The return is a number you type in and the same every month. Real investments vary and can lose money. Enter a low return too, and remember that charges and tax are not included.

Learn more